Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress (Rating 6/10): This mattress was a pretty good contender for the Best Value pick. It didn’t ultimately win because our tester found that although the outer ...

I also appreciate that it is Greenguard Gold–certified, so I felt confident that it would keep my baby girl safe. Buy this if…you want an easy-to-install (hello, white-glove delivery!) ...